📄 Subtleties of ethical messaging

A shocking amount of power is available to those who are able to communicate with extreme precision.

Copywriters have known this for the longest time, as have churches, the advertising industry, the press, demagogues, dictators, and what have you.

Of course, when a dictator tries to control dissent by putting dissidents into a Gulag it’s a bit of a ham-fisted way of communicating, but in terms of sending a message to the citizens, it’s accurate and effective.

Another and very different example is the advertising specialist doing extensive research into buyer psychology, very carefully tinkering with experiments and tests and punctuation and putting exactly the right words in exactly the right order.

And that’s where it gets tricky where it comes to ethics.

Because where is the line? When does it stop being helpful messaging and starts to look like manipulation or coercion?

The answer is: it doesn’t matter where the line is, so long as you stay far away from it.

Meaning: you have your moral compass, your values and your ethical stance, and so long as you stay true to them, you’ll be fine. Well away from the line, on the safe side of it.

But this stuff is real finicky. For instance, the other day I realised that a question I teach my clients to use is actually, subtly, not ethically optimal.

"Would it make sense to talk about what solving this would look like?"

On the surface it’s a perfectly ethical question. It asks for permission, it expresses leadership by defining a frame and guiding towards a decision, it makes no assumptions, it invites your buyer to think… nothing wrong with it. Right?

Well actually, it’s not perfect in an ethical sense. Because it turns out there’s a higher-level, more ethical version of the question:

Will it make sense to talk about what solving this would look like?

Not ‘would it make sense’, but ‘will it make sense’. Small change, big ethical difference.

Because the word ‘would’ is actually subtly manipulative: it places the buyer’s thinking in a a hypothetical exploration, but it’s much more helpful and integrous to instead point their thinking towards whether or not it will or won’t be helpful. Because that’s a cutting edge, with practical implications for their situation, their problem and the possibility of solving it, whereas hypothetical exploration is, well, hypothetical.

Of course this is an extreme technical subtlety, and you might think that it doesn’t make that much of a difference – but it does, because trust signals compound.

And since there is no neutral in trust, everything you do or say will either increase or diminish trust, subtly, and all the signals you send add up.

And because something like "Would it be helpful" is slightly more likely to diminish trust, why would you want to send a risky signal like that, instead of the more trustable ‘Will it be helpful’?

Anyway, I think that’s enough messaging nerdery for one day.

Except that when I work with entrepreneurs and I advise and edit on their messaging, mechanics like these get taught and applied, and it’s extremely effective.

Sometimes, those mechanics are less subtle – for instance, someone I work with showed me an email yesterday, a reply she received to a carefully crafted, strong but kind message, that we composed for a lead who had been on the fence for a while now,

We created a message, it included a reframe and a massive positioning statement and a price point I was sure would be rejected… but the buyer came back and said "I get it now, this makes sense, yes please let’s do it.".

Like I said: enormous power is available to those who are able to communicate with extreme precision.

This is what lights up my day: deploying my lifelong study of human nature and communication, in order for nice people to land more sales.

The Wingman service gets you that help, and can get you turnarounds like the one I mentioned, so have a look and see if it would be right for you.

Selling your work will never be easy, but being a nice person shouldn't make it harder

You shouldn't have to feel awkward about having to sell, and there's no need to feel guilty for being paid well.

But how do you ask for the sale? How to stop getting ghosted? How to get your buyer to say yes?

The answers are delivered daily, with a short article to help you land more buyers - faster and at better rates.

stand by...

Done!

Check your inbox, there's an email on the way with some free resources - see you there!

Which of these is your biggest challenge?